Do you have to put money into Metro Manufacturers IPO?


Excessive valuation dims what’s in any other case a gradual enterprise for Metro Manufacturers, with its asset-light mannequin, huge community of shops, negligible debt and good margins. On the worth band of ₹485-₹500, the PE valuation works out to somewhat over 150 instances annualised earnings of the primary half of this fiscal, on the post-issue fairness. The excessive valuation might partly be a operate of barely depressed earnings within the first half of FY22, as a result of second wave of the Covid pandemic.

To its credit score, the corporate has made income of about ₹43 crore for the April-September 2021 interval, as compared with a lack of about ₹43 crore in April-September 2020. Valuation might have additionally been influenced by that of friends resembling Bata and Relaxo which commerce at 164 instances and 106 instances FY22 earnings (Bloomberg consensus estimates) respectively.

Nevertheless, coming at a time when markets are perched on a peak and intermittent corrections have already been making markets risky, the Metro Manufacturers IPO leaves little or no margin of security for buyers at this valuation. Therefore, buyers can provide the Metro Manufacturers IPO the go by at present.

The corporate is elevating as much as ₹295 crore for opening of 260 new shops until 2025. A proposal on the market from the promoters of as much as ₹1,073 crore can also be on the playing cards.

Metro Manufacturers positives

Metro sells footwear underneath owned manufacturers resembling Metro, Mochi, DaVinchi, Vivado and Walkway (worth model) which herald about 71 per cent of the revenues in addition to third-party manufacturers resembling Clarks, Skechers, Florsheim and Crocs. The corporate operates unique enterprise retailers (EBOs) for Crocs, a premium model. Equally, Metro additionally sells one other premium model Fitflop, by its multi-brand retailers at present and can also be coming into into an association for distributing these merchandise throughout the nation. The corporate operates on an asset-light mannequin the place it outsources manufacturing to third-party producers.

Having presence within the mid and premium segments, Metro’s common promoting worth — at ₹1,300 to ₹1,350 over the past three years — is the best amongst friends resembling Bata, Khadim, Liberty and Relaxo. Among the many main manufacturers that Metro sells, Crocs brings the best realisation, adopted by Mochi/Metro and Walkway. The corporate has persistently seen 45-55 per cent repeat gross sales within the final three fiscals and within the first half of this 12 months, signalling a loyal buyer base.

Rise in urbanisation, larger disposable incomes and growing model consciousness are tailwinds for the footwear business. Crisil estimates organised retail penetration to succeed in roughly 16 per cent in fiscal 2025 from 12 per cent in fiscal 2020. On this, penetration of footwear is anticipated to the touch the next 38 per cent by FY25, boding properly for Metro which has an enormous presence on this section. As of September 30, Metro Manufacturers has a retailer rely of 598 shops throughout Metro/Mochi/Walkway/Crocs.

Metro Manufacturers financials

Income from operations stood at ₹800 crore for the 12 months ended March 2021, down from ₹1,285 crore in FY20 and ₹1,217 crore in FY19. The highest line has rebounded within the first half of this fiscal to ₹456 crore from ₹176 crore in the identical interval final 12 months. Earnings too adopted an identical trajectory, coming down from ₹153 crore in FY19 to ₹65 crore in FY21 and rebounding later. Working margins have ranged persistently over 20 per cent within the final three years, and are forward of friends resembling Bata, Khadim and Relaxo.

Identical-store gross sales development is a key metric to be watched out for shares within the retail area. However this quantity for the final three years just isn’t available within the provide doc.

In accordance with the administration, due the lockdown and different Covid-induced restrictions, this metric took a knock in FY20 and FY21 for the corporate (like many others within the retail area) though till December 2019, it confirmed a single-digit development. It has once more picked up within the second quarter of FY22, based on them.

The corporate has closed 58 shops within the final three-and-a-half years.



Break-even time for brand new shops is roughly two years. Larger variable element (linked to gross sales) in salaries of retailer stage managers helps the corporate maintain a leash on prices.

Moreover, tight stock management is one other key power which reduces discounting of merchandise and therefore, its influence on the margins. It liquidates stock (18 months or older) twice a 12 months and low cost gross sales within the final three years have been solely at 6-9 per cent of revenues.

For sure third-party manufacturers, the corporate is entitled to return sure ageing stock to the model proprietor, decreasing the stock danger too.

Debt to Fairness ratio stands at 0.1 instances as of September 30, 2021.

Supply hyperlink