If power can’t be created or destroyed, the place does it come from?

Shutterstock/Relight Movement

Herman D’Hondt

Sydney, New South Wales, Australia

It could sound unbelievable, however many scientists consider that the whole power of the universe is zero. Therefore, no power wanted to be “created” when the universe got here into existence.

Whereas it appears apparent that there’s a large quantity of power within the particles and radiation that pervade the universe, this power could also be balanced by adverse power brought on by the gravitational attraction between the particles. As Stephen Hawking defined, while you pull two objects aside, it is advisable to expend power to beat the gravity that pulls them collectively. Because it takes optimistic power to separate them, gravity should be adverse power.

If that principle is right, then there was by no means any have to create power or matter – they cancel one another out. That suggests that the massive bang may have began as a easy statistical fluctuation.

It additionally signifies that it might be potential to create our personal massive bang: simply squeeze some vacuum in the best path and bingo, a brand new universe, no power required.


Mike Follows

Sutton Coldfield, West Midlands, UK

Power could be transferred between totally different shops. Power and matter are equal, so nuclear power, for instance, begins off as matter. When a list is taken of all of the matter and power within the universe, it provides as much as zero, which appears counter-intuitive to say the least.

The zero-energy universe speculation is the only clarification of this, as outlined in 1973 by Edward Tryon, who was the primary to recommend that our universe is the results of a quantum fluctuation.

In response to Albert Einstein, mass and power are equal and, based on Tryon, the optimistic power related to mass is counterbalanced by gravitational potential power, which is adverse. Additionally, based on quantum discipline principle, particles routinely pop into and out of existence. Tryon advised that the identical may occur for a universe.


Keith Ross

Villembits, France

The quantity of power/matter within the universe is fixed and derives from the mysterious massive bang. Over time, this turns into an increasing number of unfold out and fewer and fewer helpful, although the precise quantity doesn’t change.

Take the solar for instance. Its nuclear fusion reactions flip matter (consider it as concentrated power) into seen daylight and different types of power. The daylight hits a inexperienced leaf on Earth and the photo voltaic power is now transferred right into a chemical power retailer as oxygen is separated from carbon dioxide and water, leaving carbohydrate within the leaf.

We eat the leaf and breathe within the oxygen. The respiration response in our muscle cells permits the power for use to maneuver our arm as we hammer in a nail. The arm, nail, hammer and the air take up the sound, get sizzling and radiate infrared warmth to outer area.

So the power concentrated within the authentic hydrogen atoms within the solar is now scattered into the universe. Low-grade and virtually ineffective, however nonetheless the identical quantity we began with.


To reply this query – or ask a brand new one – e-mail lastword@newscientist.com.

Questions needs to be scientific enquiries about on a regular basis phenomena, and each questions and solutions needs to be concise. We reserve the best to edit objects for readability and elegance. Please embody a postal tackle, daytime phone quantity and e-mail tackle.

New Scientist Ltd retains complete editorial management over the revealed content material and reserves all rights to reuse query and reply materials that has been submitted by readers in any medium or in any format.

Phrases and situations apply.

Supply hyperlink